Frequently
Asked Questions (FAQs)
About
the Carlsbad Habitat Management Plan (HMP)
How
large is the Carlsbad Preserve System?
At
build-out, the Preserve System is expected to be approximately 6,786
acres, consisting mostly of natural upland and wetland habitats,
including coastal sage scrub, chaparral, oak woodland, riparian scrub,
riparian forest, freshwater marsh, and grasslands. As of February 2008,
a total of 6,222 acres have been preserved (5,957 acres within the HMP
study area and an additional 265 acres within the Gnatcatcher Core Area
southeast of the City).
How
is
the Carlsbad Preserve System (also called HMP Preserve or HMP Preserve
System) being assembled?
The preserve system consists of large blocks of undeveloped
native habitats that are connected with habitat linkages, which
allow plants and animals to move between blocks of habitat.
The Carlsbad HMP Preserve System is being assembled through
a combination of the following:
- Conservation of lands already in public
ownership,
- Contributions from private development
projects, and
- Public acquisition of private lands with
regional habitat value from
willing sellers.
For more information, see Answers to
Technical Questions.
What
is
the HMP and why was it developed?
The
City of Carlsbad's Habitat Management Plan (HMP) is a regulatory
document that provides a plan for assembling the City's preserve system
and guiding development within the City. The plan promotes conservation
of habitat to support native plants and animals, active management of
conserved lands, and public use that is compatible with habitat and
species protection.
For more information, see Answers to
Technical Questions.
What
are the biological goals of the Plan?
The
overall goal of the HMP is to contribute to the regional biodiversity
and the viability of rare, unique, or sensitive biological resources
throughout the City of Carlsbad. The specific biological and
conservation objectives of the HMP are to:
- Conserve the full range of vegetation types
remaining in the City,
with a focus on rare and sensitive habitats;
- Conserve rare vegetation communities;
- Conserve areas of habitat capable of supporting
the HMP covered
species in perpetuity;
- Maintain functional wildlife corridors and
habitat linkages with the
City and the region, including linkages that connect coastal California
gnatcatcher populations and movement corridors for large mammals;
- Maintain functional biological cores;
- Conserve narrow endemic species and maintain
populations of target
species; and
- Apply a "no-net-loss" policy to the
conservation of wetlands, riparian
habitats, and oak woodland habitats throughout the City, and to coastal
sage scrub and chaparral habitats within the coastal zone.
What
is
the Carlsbad Open Space Management Plan (OSMP)?
The
OSMP is the framework management plan to implement the Carlsbad Habitat
Management Plan (HMP). It was developed with the input of the wildlife
agencies, the California Coastal Commission, and the public to
establish a process, standards, guidelines, and conditions for
long-term conservation and management of the sensitive species and
habitats within the north coastal portions of San Diego
County.
For more information, see Answers to
Technical Questions.
Who
administers the HMP?
There
are several primary entities involved in implementation of the plan,
including the (a) City of Carlsbad, (b) Preserve Steward, who helps
coordinate overall HMP implementation, (c) Preserve Managers, who have
direct responsibility for daily on-the-ground implementation, and (d)
wildlife agencies, who oversee HMP compliance. In addition, the
California Coastal Commission, broader scientific community,
environmental NGOs and the general public may assist in this effort by
reviewing and commenting on the ongoing implementation process,
associated planning documents, and annual reports.
Regulatory
Background
What
is
a Federal Habitat Conservation Plan (HCP) and Incidental Take Permit?
The
HMP qualifies as a HCP, which is a plan designed to
offset
any harmful effects that a proposed activity, such as development,
might have
on a federally threatened or endangered species. An incidental take
permit is required if "take" (harm, harass, or kill) of a threatened or
endangered species is anticipated.
For more information, see Answers to
Technical Questions.
What
is
the Natural Communities Conservation Program (NCCP)?
An NCCP identifies and provides
for the regional or area-wide protection of plants, animals, and their
habitats, while allowing compatible and appropriate economic
development. The HMP is a type of NCCP Plan.
For more information, see Answers to
Technical Questions.
What
is
the Multiple Habitat Conservation Program (MHCP)?
The MHCP is a subregional NCCP planning program designed to
develop an
ecosystem preserve in northwestern San Diego County. The
current MHCP study
area consists of
seven incorporated cities (Carlsbad,
Encinitas, Escondido, Oceanside, San Marcos, Solana Beach, and
Vista). The MHCP is a framework document under which the HMP was
developed.
For more information, see Answers to
Technical Questions.
What
is
an Implementing Agreement?
The
HMP implementing agreement contains the conservation, monitoring, and
management responsibilities, assurances of implementation, and
corresponding authorizations for the take authorization holder (City)
and the wildlife agencies.
Conservation
within the Carlsbad Preserve System
What
is open space?
The
Growth Management Plan listed open space as one of the critical 11
facilities that were important to preserving the quality of life in
Carlsbad. Developers are required to contribute fees or set aside land
for open space as they plan and develop their projects. It is important
to note that:
- "Open space" is an ambiguous term that may be
applied to many
different types of land uses.
- Cities have different models of how open space
is planned, paid for,
and maintained.
- Cities define open space according to their
general plan. There are
five different categories of "open space" defined in Carlsbad's General
Plan:
- Habitat preserved by the HMP
- Outdoor recreation
- Public health and safety
- Aesthetic, cultural, and educational uses
- Agricultural, mining, fishing, and water
management.
- There is technically no difference between
city-owned and privately
owned open space. It does not make a difference who owns the land; the
owner must comply with the zoning.
- Carlsbad has a small
percentage of city-owned open space. This relieves taxpayers of the
burden of funding, maintenance and liability.
Growth
management changed the percentage of planned open space in Carlsbad
from 25% to 40%. Current open space stands just above 33%. Since the
City is still growning and is not yet built out, future projects have
yet to dedicate their open space. It is this additional dedication of
land that will cause Carlsbad to reach the 40% total.
What
is a preserve?
A
preserve is an area set aside for the protection of native species and
vegetation communities. The land is protected by open space zoning, a
conservation easement, or other mechanism. "Preserving" land generally
refers to the securing of land for the purpose of natural resources
protection. "Conserving" land also means protecting the land, but
generally includes active management of the habitats and species within
the preserve.
Why
do
preserves need to be actively managed and monitored?
Because
of the highly urbanized condition of our region, natural habitat tends
to be fragmented and interlaced with development. This results in
larger edge-to-area ratio (i.e. smaller, isolated pieces of habitat
have more edges adjacent to development than a single, large block of
land). More edges lead to more detrimental "edge effects," which
include direct and indirect impacts from human activity. Edge effects
can include excessive noise or nighttime lighting, which can disrupt
breeding behavior of some sensitive bird species; pollutants (e.g.
pesticides, herbicides, fertilizers, discarded oil or paint thinner,
etc.) from adjacent commercial or residential land use;
impacts
from pets chasing wildlife or leaving waste which is not cleaned up by
their owners; and changes in hydrology from adjacent irrigation. For
more information on edge effects, take a look at our brochure: Help
Protect Carlsbad's Natural Open Space.
What
are
the biggest threats to the plants and animals within the preserves?
The
two greatest threats to the preserve system are invasion from
non-native plant species and unauthorized human activities. For
example, pampas grass, a common ornamental plant in backyards, can
invade natural stream courses and choke out native species that provide
habitat for sensitive bird species. This grass spreads quickly and is
very difficult and costly to remove.
Unauthorized human activities
include off-road vehicle use in areas not designated for this activity,
resulting in denuded areas, massive erosion, and sedimentation into
stream channels. There are many other things that harm native plants,
wildlife or habitats. Please see the previous question/answer for more
information.
What
is a "covered species" and which species are covered by the HMP?
A
covered species is a species that has been determined to be adequately
protected under the HMP preserve design. The HMP provides for the
conservation of 25 species.
What
is a
narrow endemic species?
Narrow
endemic species are native species with restricted geographic
distributions, soil affinities and/or habitats, and for purposes of the
HMP, species that in addition have important populations within the
Plan area, such that substantial loss of these populations or their
habitat within the HMP area might jeopardize the continued existence or
recovery of that species. A total of seventeen
narrow endemic species
have the potential to occur within the City of Carlsbad, and four of
these are covered by the HMP.
What
sensitive habitats occur with the preserve system?
The
Carlsbad Preserve System consists mostly of natural upland and wetland
habitats, including Diegan coastal sage scrub, maritime succulent
scrub, coastal sage-chaparral scrub, southern mixed chaparral, chamise
chaparral, southern maritime chaparral, native and non-native
grassland, coast live oak woodland, southern willow scrub, mulefat
scrub, southern coast live oak riparian forest, southern
cottonwood-willow riparian forest, freshwater marsh, southern coastal
salt marsh, cismontane alkali marsh, estuarine wetlands, open water,
and vernal pools.
What
is mitigation?
Mitigation
is an avoidance, minimization, or modification of a
potentially
harmful effect to native habitats or species caused by project or
activity. Much of the preserve system is being
built as mitigation for environmental impacts caused by development
projects in the City (land is being set aside and protected to mitigate
for land that is developed).
For more information, see Answers to
Technical Questions.
What
can
I do to help protect the Carlsbad natural open space?
- You can educate yourself by reading our
brochure
about edge effects,
and exploring the links
page for additional information.
- You can educate your friends and family with
what you have learned.
- You can take action in your personal life by
landscaping with native
plants, not planting invasive species, respecting preserve rules,
picking up after your pets when in a preserve, and packing out your
trash.
- You can be a citizen steward by reporting any
unlawful activities that could harm the environment, becoming active in
your Homeowners Association to protect open space owned by your HOA,
and volunteering to help maintain trails, clean up trash, or serve as a
docent. See our FAQ about volunteer opportunities.
Recreation
within the Carlsbad Preserve System
Which
areas are accessible to the public?
The
public will have access to parts of the preserve system in a way that
maintains the biological integrity of the preserve system while
allowing for public education, recreation, and enjoyment of the native
landscape. Please refer to the Preserves page for
specific information.
Why
aren't all preserve areas open to the public?
The
primary objective of the preserve system is to protect biodiversity,
natural vegetation communities, and ecological function in the
long-term. Even lawful enjoyment of the outdoors can put undue stress
on the ecosystem and cause degradation over time. Human presence often
brings noise that can disturb wildlife breeding or foraging activity,
and can cause soil erosion, invasion by non-native species, and
increased pollution. The City must balance recreational needs of the
public with protection of its biological resources. Some areas are off
limits to the public because there are sensitive species that need
protection, habitat restoration projects, wet trails that must dry out
after a heavy rain, highly erodible soils, etc.
What
recreational activities are allowed within the Carlsbad preserves?
In
general, hiking, bird-watching and other forms of passive (low-impact)
recreational activities are allowed in areas that are open to the
public. Pets are generally allowed as long as they are on a leash and
their waste is removed. Picnicking is OK as long as all associated
trash (including uneaten food) is packed out of the preserve. Note that
many preserve areas do not provide trash receptacles. Biking and
horseback riding may be allowed only in selected areas because of the
heavy impacts caused by these activities.
What
activities are prohibited in the preserves?
No
motorized vehicles are allowed anywhere in the preserve system. No
camping is allowed, and smoking, fires, and firearms are prohibited.
See additional postings at trailheads in each preserve for additional
information.
Is
the Carlsbad trail system part of the HMP Preserve System?
Some
of the trails in the Citywide Trails Program are within preserve areas
and some are not. Please see the Citywide
Trails Program website
for trail maps, guidelines for
trail use, and information on volunteering.
Landowners
How
do I know if my property is within or adjacent to the HMP Preserve?
You can look at the HMP
Preserve map to
get a general idea or call the Planning Public
Service Counter (760) 602-4610. Existing Hardline, Proposed
Hardline, and Standards areas are all part of the HMP
Preserve.
Can
I
clear vegetation for fire safety within the HMP?
Vegetation
cannot be cleared within the HMP for fire safety reasons. In most
cases, a minimum 60-ft fire suppression zone has been established
around all structures, but outside of all preserve boundaries. In some
cases, older (pre-HMP) preserves may include an area of fire
suppression within the preserve boundary. In this situation, it is the
responsibility of the preserve manager (which may be a Home Owners
Association) or the fire department to keep defensible spaces cleared.
If
my land is included within the HMP planning area, will I be still able
to develop my land?
Yes,
but all new projects must be consistent with the HMP. If your property
falls within a "Standards Area" (see HMP map)
your project will be
required to comply with the zone-specific standards described in the
HMP. If your property falls within the Coastal Zone, your
project
must comply with the Coastal Zone Conservation Standards. Projects
adjacent to the preserve must adhere to the Adjacency Standards.
How
will being in the HMP Planning Area affect the processing of my
subdivision/permit?
HMP compliance will be analyzed concurrently with CEQA compliance,
thereby streamlining the permitting process.
What
do I need to know if my property is adjacent to a preserve
area?
The
HMP planning area is an urban wildlife preserve system in which
conserved habitat areas are adjacent to development of various types.
In order to prevent negative impacts to the preserve, Adjacency
Standards must be addressed during the planning process of
projects
adjacent the preserve lands. These standards include the following
issues:
- Fire management
- Erosion control
- Landscaping restrictions
- Fencing, signs and lighting
- Predator and exotic species control
Contact
Information
How
do I find out more information about the Carlsbad Preserve System?
Email
us: hmp.ci.carlsbad.ca.us
Or
call us:
Mike Grim, City HMP Coordinator (760) 602-4623
OR
Rosanne Humphrey, Carlsbad Preserve Steward
(760) 519-0873.
How
can I find out about volunteer opportunities?
Please see the City's Volunteer
Opportunities
website.
Who
can I contact if I have questions about the trails in Carlsbad?
Please see the Citywide
Trails Program website
to find out more.
Who
can I contact if I see some illegal activities occurring within a
preserve area?
For
emergencies call
911
For
non-emergencies:
Email
us: hmp.ci.carlsbad.ca.us
Or
call us:
Mike Grim, City HMP Coordinator (760) 602-4623
OR
Rosanne Humphrey, Carlsbad Preserve Steward
(760) 519-0873.
Who
can I contact if I see potential threats to species or habitats, such
as erosion or invasive species, within a preserve area?
Email
us: hmp.ci.carlsbad.ca.us
Or
call us:
Mike Grim, City HMP Coordinator (760) 602-4623
OR
Rosanne Humphrey, Carlsbad Preserve Steward
(760) 519-0873.
|